College Players & All-Americans
Program history since 1990
College Commitments
| Player | Year | Position | School |
|---|---|---|---|
| James Yap | 1991 | Goalie | D1 Michigan State University |
| Eric Schaeffer | 1994 | Attack | D3 Wittenberg University |
| James Reed | 1994 | Midfield | D1 Ohio State University |
| Andrew Durniat | 1997 | Defense | D3 Ohio Wesleyan University |
| Michael Durniat | 2000 | Attack | D3 Ohio Wesleyan University |
| Chris Nixon | 2004 | Midfield | D3 Wooster College |
| Ryan McMahon | 2004 | Attack | D3 Wooster College |
| Brian Masterson | 2006 | Attack | D2 Queens University Charlotte |
| Connor Martin | 2009 | Midfield | D1 Robert Morris |
| Riley Seidel | 2009 | Attack | D1 Colorado |
| John Emmenecker | 2013 | Midfield | D1 Robert Morris |
| Jonathan Yobaggy | 2013 | LSM | D3 Adrian College |
| Spencer Lonseth | 2013 | Attack | D2 University of Tampa |
| Cameron Happel | 2014 | Midfield | D2 Mercyhurst |
| Jacob Ransom | 2014 | Defense | D2 Walsh University |
| Nate Miller | 2014 | Attack | D3 Wooster College |
| Bo Taylor | 2017 | LSM | D3 Albion |
| Nathan Steinmetz | 2018 | Defense | D3 Mount Union |
| Chandler Bankey | 2019 | Attack | D3 John Carroll |
| Nathan Aloi | 2019 | Midfield | D3 John Carroll |
| Sam Rodgers | 2019 | Defense | D3 John Carroll |
| Ryan Pierce | 2020 | Goalie | D3 Capital |
| Andrew Miller | 2021 | Attack | D3 Albion |
| Quinn Staten | 2023 | Midfield | D1 Cincinnati (football) |
| Will Bohne | 2023 | Midfield | D1 Monmouth |
| Zachary Zitkovic | 2023 | Midfield | D2 Hillsdale (football) |
| Owen Winkler | 2024 | FOGO | D3 Muskingum |
| Ty Sadowy | 2024 | Goalie/Defense | D3 Heidelberg |
| Kyler Ayers | 2025 | Defense | D3 Hope College |
| Ryan Kosola | 2026 | Attack | D3 Alma |
| Caleb DeLong | 2027 | Attack | D2 Thomas More |
| Jake Pieron | 2027 | Defense | D2 Palm Beach Atlantic University |
All-Americans
- Bennett Miller — Attack, 2016
Academic All-Americans
- Ron Erdelyi — 2007
- Bennett Miller — Attack, 2016
- Nathan Aloi — Midfield, 2019
- Quinn Wiklendt — Attack, 2024
- Alexander Speer — Attack, 2025
Collegiate All-Americans
- Andrew Durniat — Defense, D3 Ohio Wesleyan University, 2001 (HM)